Negative Staining
In order to visualize a specimen in the TEM it is necessary
to create what is known as image contrast. By this we mean that
there must exist regions of varying electron opacity such that
differences can be detected and therefore information about the
structure of the specimen can be discerned. This is accomplished
by the differential scattering, deflecting, and stopping of
illuminating electrons. For an object to have a level of
electron opacity there must be enough nuclear mass present to
accomplish this deflection of electrons. A thick biological
specimen meets this requirement by having a large number of
relatively low atomic weight atoms aligned relative to the
incident electron beam.
A second way of accomplishing this is to have a relatively
thin layer of high atomic weight elements aligned relative to the
incident beam.
This same principle is utilized in the positive staining of
biological specimens to selectively give electron contrast to
different portions of the specimen. The primary distinction
between positive and negative staining is that in positive
staining the stain forms a complex with the specimen whereas in
negative staining the stain and the specimen do not react with
one another. Also as the name implies a positive stain will
impart increased electron opacity to the specimen creating a
darker specimen whereas in negative staining the specimen remains
more electron translucent relative to the surrounding stain. By
pooling up around the edges and crevices of the specimen and not
as much on the top portions of the specimen an image of
differential contrast of the specimen can be made.
[5-13 bozzala]
Negative Staining Cont'd
One of the limitations of negative staining is that only
information about the microtopography of the specimen is
produced. Little or nothing is learned about the internal
structure. Some of the main advantages of negative staining over
conventional preparation of biological specimens are:
1) Improved resolution - Often a resolution of 10 A or less is
possible under the right conditions with negative staining. This
is a vast improvement over conventionally sectioned material in
which spatial resolution is also limited by z-dimension or
section thickness.
2) Speed - The process of negative staining is exceptionally fast
and it is possible to go from living organism to observing it in
the microscope in only a matter of minutes. This is in contrast
with conventional preparation that can take days to complete.
3) Unique Information - Not only can detailed information be
learned about the topography and therefore the three dimensional
nature of the specimen, but samples can be examined that could
not be visualized in conventional preparations. These include
selectively isolated components from cell fractionation (nuclear,
RER, SER, chloroplast, mitochondria, etc.) as well as specially
prepared or isolated biomolecules (ribosomes, DNA, specific
enzymes, glycoproteins, etc.). Also specimens that do not lend
themselves to conventional preparation (isolated viruses,
bacteria, non-biological specimens, etc.).
4) Simplicity - Little in the way of special equipment or
reagents is needed.
There are however a number of disadvantages to negative staining.
1) Repeatability - The technique is straight forward but can
often yield greatly varying results both between samples and even
on the same grid.
2) Limited to surface topology of small structures. There are
many applications where negative staining has no value.
3) Toxicity - While this is no more dangerous than in
conventional specimen preparation the heavy metal stains used in
negative staining are highly toxic.
The choice of negative stain is usually based on four
criteria:
A) Stain should be of high density to provide high contrast.
This usually involves the use of some heavy metal with great
electron stopping or scattering capabilities.
B) It should have a high solubility (80g/100 ml) so that it does
not come out of solution during the final stages of drying. It
should also have minimal reactivity with the specimen at the
concentrations used.
C) Should have a high melting and boiling point so that it does
not volatilize under the beam. Since it will absorb much of the
beam and its incident energy it must be beam stable.
D) The precipitate formed must be of extremely fine grain so that
it appears as amorphous down to the limit of resolution. It is
difficult to visualize a ping- pong ball surrounded by dark
bowling bowls.
Some of the best materials for negative staining are
phosphotungstate (and other phosphotungstic acid salts), sodium
tungstate, uranyl acetate, and uranyl nitrate.
A generalized procedure for negative staining is as follows:
A) An electron transparent support film is produced on which to
deposit the specimen. Often this is a Formvar or collodion film.
The support film is often coated with a thin layer of carbon
which adds rigidity and strength to the film but can also produce
a hydrophobic film that will inhibit the even spreading of
specimen and stains. Others prefer a pure carbon film because of
its finer grain size and over come the hydrophobicity problem by
using a glow discharge unit or other means of reducing the
hydrophobic effect.
B) A thin suspension of the specimen is placed on the film
covered grid and all but a tiny excess is removed with a small
piece of filter paper. The remainder is allowed to dry
completely to the film. Care must be taken that the
concentration of specimen not be too great or too low. If excess
salts are deposited during the drying process they must often be
removed by post wetting the grid after attachment to the film or
by resuspending the specimen in a salt free medium immediately
prior to deposition. Often a spreading agent such as photoflo or
0.4% sucrose is added to the specimen, stain or both to insure a
more even distribution of material.
C) After complete drying of the specimen a thin layer of negative
stain is similarly applied, removed and allowed to dry. Just the
right amount of stain must be allowed to dry to reveal but not
obscure the structure of interest. The pH of the stain as well
as the length of time of application before drying will determine
to what extent positive staining is eliminated although it always
contributes a small amount to the final image. It often takes
the making of many grids and looking at many different grid
squares on each grid to find that portion where all the ideals
coincided.
D) Once the stain is completely dry the grid may be examined in
the TEM. Samples are generally stable and can be stored
desiccated for many months or years.
Replicas and Shadowing
A second method for examining the surface topology and
structures of specimens in a TEM employs shadowing techniques.
In this case the image contrast is produced by the uneven
distribution of fine metal particles. Once again electron dense
metals are the coatings of choice and platinum, chromium,
palladium, uranium, and gold are some of the more commonly used
metals for shadowing. Also, as the name implies information
about the surface topology is gained by creating a shadow effect
which is directly proportional to the microarchitecture of the
specimen. This is accomplished by depositing the coating metal
from a low angle (5 - 30 degrees) relative to the general plane
of the specimen. The greater the height of portions of the
specimen the larger will be the resultant shadow. The contrast
difference created by a shadow that is created is opposite to a
shadow produced by sunlight.
[diagram this]
In interpreting a shadowed preparation it is important to
know the direction from which metal was deposited. In fact if
the angle and direction of the shadowing source are known
relative to the specimen the height of the specimen can be
calculated using the equation:
H = tan O X l Where H = height of specimen
O = angle of shadowing
l = length of shadow
or H = b/c X l Where b = Height from level to source
c = Distance from sample to source
[fig L-2 Wischnitzzer]
Shadowing may be done from a fixed angle (static shadowing) or on
a rotating specimen (rotary shadowing). Rotary shadowing allows
one to resolve portions of the specimen that might otherwise have
been obscured by the shadow.
As with negative staining resolution in the TEM of shadowed
specimens is dependent on the grain size of the deposited metal.
Basically there are three methods of depositing thin metal films
for shadowing preparations these being a) heated electrodes, b)
electron beam gun (often called an e-gun or electron gun), and c)
cathodic etching.
A) Heated Electrodes - With heated electrode evaporation the
material to be deposited is heated by passing a large electrical
current through it while maintaining it under high vacuum
conditions (10-6 to 10-7 Torr). The material then begins to
volatilize (boil) and is evaporated in all directions into the
vacuum chamber. Some of the metal particles will strike the
specimen and create a shadow depending on the topography of the
sample and the angle of the incoming particles. The most common
device for accomplishing this is a vacuum evaporator and this is
still the most common means of depositing metal or carbon. The
higher the vacuum at the time of evaporation the finer will be
the grain size. For this reason liquid nitrogen is often added to
the system to act as a cryogenic pump immediately before
shadowing.
B) Electron Beam Evaporation - This technique is similar to the
heated electrodes method only in this case electrons emitted from
a surrounding tungsten filament (which emits electrons due to
thermionic emission) strike the target and causes it to heat.
The fine particles are then emitted from the source and are free
to strike the specimen. Once again this type of deposition takes
place under high vacuum conditions in vacuum chamber. Because
electrons are the source of heat in these deposition devices they
are often referred to as electron guns or "e-guns" but should not
be confused with the electron gun assembly that is the source of
imaging electrons in a TEM.
C) Cathode Etching (Sputtering) - In Cathodic Etching ionized
molecules of an inert gas (usually high purity argon) are focused
and accelerated to bombard a cathode target. The target consists
of a thin foil of high purity heavy metal (gold or
gold/palladium). The gas ions displace molecules of metal from
the target which are then free to go toward the specimen
(sputter) and coat it. Because little or no heat is generated in
the process cathode etching is also known as a "cold" source
technique. Unless special equipment is used the size of the
deposited metal grains in sputtering are often quite large and
although may be suitable for SEM are not suitable for high
resolution TEM imaging.
Shadowing is used on many of the same types of samples and
for many of the same reasons as is negative staining. As with
negative staining only information about the surface of the
specimen is really obtained. One often goes through the trouble
of shadowing (as opposed to just negative staining) because of
the added resolution that can be obtained, especially with low
angle rotary shadowing. Shadow casts can be made of any stable
dried organic or inorganic molecule of organism that will not
change shape under high vacuum conditions. The shadow cast can
be made on an intermediate substrate such as a piece of mica and
then removed or directly on a Formvar or carbon film on a grid
which is then placed directly in the TEM. It is common to
deposit the electron dense metal from a predetermined angle to
create the shadow effect and then to evaporated from directly
above, a fine layer of carbon which does not add much electron
opacity but does provide strength to the shadow cast,
particularly in regions where no metal was deposited.
A modification of shadow technique is known as replication.
In forming a replica many of the same steps employed in creating
a shadow cast (metal and carbon deposition under vacuum on an
intermediate substrate) are used. The shadow cast is then
removed from the substrate by floating on water and the pieces
placed in a solution to remove the biological or mineral sample.
Strong acids (hydrochloric, chromic, hydrofluoric) or bases
(sodium hypochlorite) are used, sometimes in succession, to
dissolve away the original biological material and leave only the
metal/carbon cast or "replica" of the original specimen. This is
often extremely useful in that the original material may have
been electron dense enough to prevent visualization of the fine
shadow produced on the surface of the specimen. It is also
important in making a replica that there be sufficient carbon
deposited to make the replica strong enough so that it will hold
up in the TEM. The tiny floating replica fragments are rinsed in
water and picked up on naked 300 mesh grids and examined in the
TEM. Thus there is no support film present as there is in shadow
casts.
A modification of the replica technique is when a replica is
made of a frozen sample. This is known as freeze etching or
freeze fracture. We will discuss this technique when we cover
cryobiology.
In some cases the sample may not lend itself to direct
replication and in this case a two step replica (negative
replica, reverse replica) may be made. This is done by first
making a plastic replica of the specimen by applying liquid
plastic to the original specimen. After the plastic hardens the
specimen is then removed from the either by peeling or
dissolving. The first stage plastic replica is then subjected to
metal and carbon deposition as before and the plastic removed
from the second stage replica by dissolving in an organic
solvent. The metal/carbon replica is then examined in the TEM.
Cases in which one might make a two stage replica include rare or
large specimens that cannot be sacrificed or specimens that must
be used for a second purpose.
In terms of resolution shadow casting, especially low angle
rotary shadowing, can equal or exceed the resolution capable from
negative staining. Replication is really the only technique
available for examining the surface features of an electron dense
specimen in the TEM.
Cryopreservation
One alternative to standard chemical fixation is the use of
low-temperature methods otherwise known as cryopreservation. In
cryopreservation samples are rapidly frozen and then further
processed using a variety of techniques.
Essentially the same goals of standard fixation apply here
namely to arrest cellular processes rapidly and preserve the cell
in as near to the living state as possible. We have a lot of
confidence that this is the case with cryopreservation as it has
been shown that rapidly frozen cells can remain viable following
warming. Cryopreservation offers a number of advantages over
conventional fixation among these are:
1) Rapid arrest of cellular processes. One is not dependent on
the speed of penetration of the fixative. (milliseconds vs.
seconds)
2) Avoidance of artifacts induced by changes in osmolarity, pH,
or chemical imbalance.
3) Because cellular constituents are not subjected to biochemical
alterations they remain in more of their natural configuration.
Labile components are retained and antigenicity is usually
improved.
4) Cells can be examined without introduction of other possible
artifacts caused by dehydration or embedding.
5) One can examine cellular domains that might otherwise be
inaccessible (e.g. IMPs) or from a view that is usually not
possible (e.g. 3-D view via deep etch).
There are however a number of disadvantages as well and among
these are:
1) The need for specialized freezing and processing equipment
(-80 freezer, cryoultramicrotome, freeze fracture device, etc.)
2) Freeze damage due to poor freezing rates.
3) Limited view of specimen and or difficulty in manipulating the
frozen material.
Rapid Freezing:
The major obstacle to good cryopreservation is the
introduction of artifacts due to formation of ice crystals that
disrupt the cellular structure. The goal of rapid freezing is to
prevent the formation of ice crystals and preserve the aqueous
component of the cell in near to the vitreous state. Vitreous
refers to glass or glass like, and just as glass is really a
supercooled liquid and not a solid, water can also exist in this
quasi-solid state. In general this is very difficult to
accomplish with biological samples and usually we simply strive
to keep ice crystal formation to a minimum which is often defined
as whether or not the crystals are visible in the electron
microscope. This cannot be accomplished by simply putting the
sample in the freezer.
Cryopreservation Cont'd
Perhaps the most important aspect of rapid freezing is the
choice of cryogen or freezing medium. A good cryogen should have
several properties.
1) Low freezing point - need to have a good thermal gradient
between the sample and the cryogen.
2) High boiling point - must minimize the formation of a vapor
barrier near specimen due to latent heat of sample. The
formation of an insulating vapor barrier around the sample is
known as the leidenfrost or "bad frost" phenomenon and prevents
the cryogen from making direct contact with the surface of the
sample. This tends to slow the freezing rate and produce ice
crystals.
3) It should have a high heat capacity and thermal conductivity
(latent heat). In plain terms it should be able to absorb heat
without increasing its own temperature. Because of this low
molecular weight liquids such as N2 and He tend not to very good
cryogens.
Cryogen melting pt. boiling pt.
Freon 22 -160 -40.8
Freon 13 -181 -81.1
Freon 12 -155 -29.8
isopentane -160 27.85
propane -189 -42
nitrogen -209 -196
ethane -183 -88.6
helium -272 (1o K) -268.9
An alternative to liquid cryogens is the use of a nitrogen slurry
or slush. By lowering the pressure of liquid nitrogen it can be
induced to freeze and become a solid. When brought back to room
pressure the liquid and solid nitrogen exist side by side. Just
as a glass of ice and water remains at 4 degrees longer than does
a glass of pure 4 degree water, the nitrogen slush has a higher
latent heat and can thus absorb more heat from the sample before
boiling. This reduces the leidenfrost effect and improves
freezing rates.
The rate at which a specimen freezes is usually the
determining factor in the amount of ice crystal formation and
subsequent damage there is. Slow freezing rates such as 1 C/min
results in significant damgae. The extracellular water freezes
first and pulls out the water from the cell as the concentration
gradient changes. In general cells do not contain large amounts
of unbound water so the formation of very large ice crystals
usually does not happen but the specimen can become shrunken and
distorted.
Rapid freezing is usually defined as a change in temperature
in excess of 10,000 C/sec. (vs. 1 C/min). One of the major
problems associated with rapid freezing is the total amount of
heat that must removed from the specimen. If internal heat from
the specimen continues to warm those portions that are cooling it
will prevent the water from undergoing a rapid phase change and
large ice crystals can form. For this reason the size of the
specimen should be kept to a minimum regardless of the freezing
method used and the specimen carrying device should be made of a
small amount of material that has excellent thermal conductivity.
Thin pieces of copper or gold are usually used.
Cryopreservation Cont'd
Specimens are then rapidly placed or "plunged" into the
cryogen and held there for 20 - 30 seconds. It is important that
the specimen be as small as possible as good freezing will only
occur on the outer surface and one wants to reduce the heat load
placed on the cryogen. Plunge freezing is best used on very
small specimens or cell suspensions.
One problem associated with plunge freezing is the fact that
as the cryogen removes heat from the specimen it begins to warm
up. This is a localized effect but results in either a decrease
in the thermal gradient between the cryogen and specimen or even
worse in the formation of leidenfrost. To avoid this it is
desirable to have a fresh supply of cryogen constantly moving
over the sample and taking away any excess heat with it. This
can be done by either moving the sample rapidly through the
cryogen (projectile freezing) or moving the cryogen past a
stationary specimen. This is the theory behind jet freezing.
The most commonly used cryogen for jet freezing is liquid propane
and the device is known as a propane jet freezer. Basically the
unit operates by putting the specimen on a very thin support foil
or holder and then placing it between two thin pipe with opposing
ports. Liquid propane (which was liquefied by a bath of liquid
nitrogen) is stored in a bomb underneath the output ports and is
then forced out from the ports under great pressure by
introducing dry nitrogen to the the propane bomb. Two opposing
streams of liquid propane the hit the specimen from both sides
and carry away the excess heat. Cooling rates of 30,000 C/sec
have been claimed for propane jet freezing and heat exchange is 2
- 30 times faster than with plunge freezing alone. These are
dangerous to use and we are experimenting now with a device I
helped to design which uses six ports (3 above, 3 below) that
uses a stream of liquid nitrogen.
A second alternative to rapid freezing samples with liquids
is to bring them in rapid contact with a very cold surface.
Although this will result in severe ice damage in the sample that
is not immediately in contact with the surface, it can produce
excellent results in the region immediately adjacent to the
surface. Contact freezing is accomplished by pre-cooling a large
metal block (usually polished copper, brass, or gold) and then
rapidly bringing the sample in contact with the block. Because
latent heat and leidenfrost is not a concern in this method one
simply wants to create the largest thermal gradient possible.
For this reason liquid nitrogen or even better liquid helium is
used. The primary reason that most researchers choose to use
liquid nitrogen is that it costs approximately 45 cents per liter
whereas liquid helium costs $200 per liter.
One problem with bringing the sample in contact with the
block is the possibility that it will bounce and thus damage the
specimen. For this reason a special freeze slamming device is
used that has a glycerol hydraulic damping system to drop the
specimen onto the block but prevent it from bouncing. A
modification of this procedure involves grabbing the specimen
between two precooled metal surfaces. These cryopliers are
widely used in cryopreservation of specimens such as muscle
fibers.
A modification of surface freezing is known as spray
freezing. In spray freezing the sample in the form of a
suspension is spray or atomized onto a precooled metal block or
into a cryogen. This avoids the problems of bouncing and keeps
specimen size to a minimum (1 ul or less volume). It has the
disadvantage that the specimen must be one that can be sprayed
and is often difficult to handle afterwards as it must be
collected without rewarming the sample.
Cryopreservation Cont'd
The latest in freezing devices is known as a high pressure
freezer. At extreme pressures of 2100 bar (Bar = 1 ATM = 760 mm
Hg) the nucleation of ice is significantly reduced. A second
thing that happens is that the melting point of water is lowered
to - 22C (vs. 0 C at 1 ATM). This is one reason that cold water
on the ocean bottom does not freeze. At these pressures the
critical cooling rate is raised to 100 C/sec (vs. 10,000 C/sec at
1 ATM). The device works by initially pressurizing the chamber
with isopropanol followed by liquid nitrogen. Because the cells
are pressurized for only a few milliseconds before the LN2 is
introduced they are generally not harmed too much. LN2 can be
used because at these pressures it will not boil so no
leidenfrost is formed.
Device freezing depth cost
Plunge freezer 10 - 20 um $ 0.50
- 50
Spray Freezer 10 - 20 um $ 10 -
50
Slam Freezer 20 -40 um $ 2000
Propane Jet 40 um $
10,000
High Pressure 50 - 100 um $
150,000
Cryoprotectants:
Regardless of the freezing method used many specimens are
treated with a cryoprotectant to reduce the possibility of ice
damage. Cryoprotectants function by both increasing the number
of ice nuclei and retarding the growth of ice crystals. By
either binding to water molecules or substituting for water
molecules cryoprotectants reduce the number of water molecules
available for binding to growing ice nuclei and thus greatly slow
the growth of these crystals. Generally cryoprotectants are
viscous and in this way they also slow down the rate of diffusion
of water from the specimen as the exterior water freezes. This
helps to reduce the shrinkage effects of slow freezing. Some
commonly used cryoprotectants are glycerol (penetrating type) or
sucrose (non- penetrating type) and are generally used in
concentrations of 10-30%. One of the disadvantages of
cryoprotectants is that it has been shown that extensive exposure
to cryoprotection can alter the internal structure by applying
osmotic pressure to the cytoplasm. Usually marine organisms have
a number of dissolved salts in the medium which act as
cryoprotectants and often these can be frozen without further
cryoprotection.
One of the things that can be done with rapidly frozen
samples is to replace the aqueous component of the specimen with
an organic solvent without allowing the to change from its frozen
arrested state. During the freeze subsitution process a rapidly
frozen sample is held for one to two days in a vial of organic
solvent at -80 C. Over this time period the frozen water
molecules are replaced or "substituted" by molecules of the
organic solvent. This happens despite the fact that the water is
never allowed to return to the liquid state. Acetone is usually
the solvent of choice although ethanol and methanol have been
used as well. The organic solvents have some fixitive properties
of their own which can be enhanced by the addition of standard
fixitives such as osmium tetroxide. Recently anhydrous
glutaraldehyde has become available for use in organic solvents
during freeze substitution. Thus the cells are chemically cross
linked and fixed before their components have an opportunity to
change from their frozen positions. The samples are then
gradually brought to room temperature (done slowly to prevent
renucleation of ice crystals), the fixitive, if any, rinsed out
with pure organic solvent, and infiltrated and embedded as usual.
Thus in freeze substitution the fixation and dehydration steps
are combined into a single step.
One great advantage of rapid freezing and freeze
substitution as oppposed to standard chemical fixation is that
many of the artifacts associated with chemical fixation can be
eliminated or greatly reduced. A prime example of this is in the
study of membranes and membrane bound organelles. The length of
time a fixitive takes to penetrate a cell and the changes it
induces in terms of periability often results in shrinkage or
wrinkling of membranes and membrane bound organelles. If one
compares these to chemically prepared cells the smoothness and
roundness of freeze substituted material is quite surprising.
Also rapid cellular processes such as the fusion of membrane
bound vesicles can be captured because although the fusion
process itself is very rapid, the freezing rate is even faster.
A second great advantage of freeze substitution is seen when
one uses the fixation properties of the organic solvent alone to
preserve the cell. This has the great advantage of hlding all
cellular components in place while at the same time not cross
linking the cell so completely that not cytochemistry can be
done. In fact cells preserved in this way have better
ultrastructural preservation and greater ability to react in
cytochemical treatments than any other method. A variety of
methacrylate resins have been developed which facilitate
immunocytochemical processing of cells including Lowicryl which
remains a liquid down to - 40 C and can be polymerized at that
temperature using U.V. light. Thus cells are freeze substituted,
infiltrated, and polymerized without ever regaining the unfrozen
state. Cell structures and biochemicals can therefore be
preserved in nearly their native state.
Freeze Drying & Distillation:
A modification of the freeze substitution process is known
as freeze drying or in some cases as "cryodistillation." In
freeze drying the rapidly frozen specimen is held cold under
vacuum and its water is allowed to sublimate (go directly from
solid to gas). Once all the water has been removed a low
termperature embedding resin (Lowicryl) is introduced, allowed to
infiltrate under vaccum and eventually polymerized and sectioned.
Cryodistillation has the advantage that water soluable components
are not extracted from their nave position during the
substitution process and thus much can be learned about the
natural biochemical composition of the cell.
Cryosectioning:
Yet another technique that can take advantage of rapidly
frozen specimens is cryosectioning or "cryoultramicrotomy." In
cryosectioning the specimen is sectioned while still in the
frozen state and before any post processing (substitution,
distillation, etc) has been done. Frozen sections are thin
enough for examination in the TEM and this can be done either on
the cold sections using a cryotransfer system which keeps the
sections at liquid nitrogen tempertures or on warmed specimens
that have been allowed to dry down onto a grid. Generally the
ultrastructural preservation of cryosectioned material is quite
poor. The primary reason for using cryosections is the enhanced
antigenic reactions that one can get from unfixed, unembedded
material. The major drawback (other than poor structural
preservation) is that cryosections are exceptionally difficult to
make and the technique and equipment needed are tough to master
and expensive. Despite this cryoultramicrotomy can allow one to
immunolocalize structures at the TEM level that would otherwise
be impossible to do with conventional methods.
Freeze Fracture
At times it is important that one examine a replica of a
specimen that has not been dried but rather is in the hydrated
state. For these applications one would use the technique of
freeze etching or freeze fracture. The key element of freeze
fracture is that the platinum/carbon replica is made on a frozen
specimen that is contained within a vacuum evaporator. In those
cases where actual fracturing of the specimen is important a
mechanical microtome that can be cooled to liquid nitrogen
temperatures and operated within the vacuum evaporator is also
employed. As could be expected, these specialized vacuum
evaporators or Freeze-fracture devices, are quite expensive often
costing as much or more than the TEMs for which they prepare
specimens.
Freeze fracture operates on the principle that a specimen
that is held in place frozen in ice can be treated like a solid
rigid structure and broken or fractured in various regions of the
specimen. These newly fractured surfaces may run along the
original surface of the specimen but are more likely to pass
through the internal portion of the specimen. Thus a replica
made of these newly exposed surfaces can reveal important
information about the internal composition of a specimen, not
just the exterior as in normal dry shadow casts or replicas. As
with other cryotechniques the size of the ice crystals formed is
especially important in freeze fracture and specimens are usually
prepared using one of the rapid freezing techniques previously
discussed (plunge freezing, jet freezing, slam freezing, high
pressure freezing).
To prepare a freeze fracture replica a small amount of the
sample is placed on a small metal carrier sometimes referred to
as a "hat." These hats are often made of gold due to the ability
of this metal to conduct heat rapidly away from the specimen.
The hats are then rapidly frozen and stored in liquid nitrogen
until ready for use. In the mean time the freeze fracture device
is warmed up and brought down to high vacuum using a
diffusion/mechanical pump system. The cold specimen on hats are
then rapidly transferred to a stage which has been cooled under
vacuum by liquid nitrogen flowing through the stage. The chamber
is then rapidly pumped down again while the stage and specimens
remain at LN temperatures. Now the microtome arm assembly with
attached razor blade is cooled to -195 C with LN while the stage
and specimens are gradually raised to about -100 C. The cooled
knife is then rotated over the specimen until contact is just
made and thin shavings are removed from the top surface. These
shavings are not sections and the specimen is not so much
sectioned as it is scraped. Although a razor blade is used the
analogy is closest to a huge snow plow clearing a snow covered
dirt road. As it makes contact small pieces and chunks are torn
loose from the road revealing exposed frozen surfaces. After a
sample has been scraped and a clean surface exposed the sample is
often "etched" for a period of 1-3 minutes. During this process
the cold knife hovers above the fractured specimen while both are
held under vacuum. The combined effect of high vacuum and a
temperature differential (-150 vs. -100) causes some of the
frozen surface water of the specimen to sublimate (go directly
from water to gas) and be removed by the vacuum system. As this
happens the non-aqueous components of the specimen become more an
more prominent relative to the flat background. A variation on
this technique involves deep etching followed by rotary
shadowing. Using this technique large relief images can be
created of structures that are only visible in the TEM.
A modification of this technique is known as double replica
or complementary replica formation. In this process the sample
is initially frozen sandwiched between two planchets which are
then inserted into a special precooled holder. This holder is
then flipped apart while on the cold stage and the specimen is
split in two exposing matching surfaces. A replica of each
surface is then made and examined. In this way both surfaces can
be viewed whereas the opposite surface is scraped away in
conventional fracturing.
One of the most useful and widespread applications of freeze
fracture is in the study of biological membranes and their
various protein components. To understand why we need to look at
how a biological membrane is organized. Basically all biological
membranes are composed of two layers of phospholipids arranged so
that their hydrophobic regions face one another. Embedded in
this phospholipid sandwich are intramembranous particles (IMPs)
which are proteins or protein complexes that span from one
hydrophilic side of the membrane to the other. In addition to
these IMPs there may or may not be additional protein complexes
that are embedded in one half or the other of the membrane.
[Fig. 14-1]
When a cooled razor blade contacts a frozen specimen the
membrane selectively splits apart at the hydrophobic junction.
This occurs because at reduced temperatures the energy needed to
split the hydrophobic junction of the membrane is less than that
needed to split the ice or aqueous components of the cell. A
replica made of a fractured surface typically reveals large
portions of the internal region of biological membranes. In
fact, freeze fracture is about the only technique available that
allows one to visualize the hydrophobic regions of membranes. Of
course other structures such as nuclei, flagella, and cell walls
are also fractured during this process.
As difficult as it is to make a good freeze fracture
replica, it is often even more difficult to interpret one. Part
of the reason for this is made clear in looking at the following
illustration. Conventional scientific illustration usually
places the light source in the upper left hand corner of the
image at an angle of about 45 degrees relative to the specimen.
Most SEMs follow this convention when designing the scan pattern,
detector position, and display monitor. Based on this we
conclude that an object is convex when the dark shadow produced
by light is in the lower right hand corner of the image and
concave when it falls in the upper left hand corner. Because
cells are mostly composed of spherical vesicles and curved
membranes, the freeze fracture image is a case study in this type
of illustration. The first problem that one then encounters in
interpreting freeze fractures is the fact that lights and darks
of shadows are reversed from those made by light. For this
reason some people initially find it easier to interpret their
micrographs from the photographic negative rather than the
positive image. A second problem is the fact that when a replica
is placed into the TEM there is virtually no way to know before
hand the angle of shadow (direction from which metal was
deposited). After cleaning, and picking up tiny replica
fragments on grids and then placing them into the TEM nearly any
orientation is possible. Two things can help to orient the
viewer of a freeze fracture replica. The first is any known
structure that the operator knows to be convex in nature. IMPs
are an excellent example of these. Using the shadow produced by
the convex structure the direction of shadow can be determined
and the micrograph oriented so that convex structures appear
convex and concave ones appear concave. A strategically
convenient piece of dirt that fell on the surface of the sample
immediately before the replica was made can also fill this
function.
One problem that arose when freeze fractures began to be
widely used by electron microscopists was that of terminology.
Before freeze fracture a biological membrane could be thought of
as a single sheet with two (hydrophilic) surfaces. Now suddenly
scientists had four different surfaces to deal with and a way was
needed to clearly distinguish between them. A paper by [?]
created the guidelines by which all other freeze fracture images
would be labeled. The first rule that was suggested is that the
membrane be broken down into surface (hydrophilic) and fracture
(hydrophobic) profiles. These were abbreviated as the "S" and
"F" designations. The other way distinguishing which surface is
being discussed is to determine whether the half of the membrane
in question was in contact with the protoplasmic (P) portion of
the cell or the endoplasmic (E) portion. Thus any given
biological membrane can be spoken in terms of four surfaces or
"faces"; going from the outside of the cell towards the cytoplasm
the plasmamembrane would be designated as having a ES face, a EF
face, a PF face and a PS face. This designation system becomes
tricky when one begins talking about double membrane bound
systems (nuclear envelope, mitochondrion, chloroplasts) but none
the less is clear and unambiguous. Double replica formation is
especially useful in this case for both the EF and PF faces of a
given membrane can be viewed and the relative abundance of IMPs
on each can be determined.
Immunoelectron Microscopy
Immunoelectron microscopy as defined here has a broader
definition than strictly antibody-antigen reaction. Under the
broad definition it includes the labeling of biochemicals so that
their localization can be visualized in the TEM. In order to
visualize this in the TEM we must in some way tag or label the
biochemical of interest with an electron dense marker that
distinguishes it from other cellular components. Some techniques
that come under this category are lectin-horseradish peroxidase
reaction, biotin-avidin conjugates, as well as antibody-antigen
reactions.
An immuno response is one in which an organism exposed to a
foreign body develops a resistance to that type of body so that
it is resistant or "immune" to infection from future exposure to
a similar type of body. Any substance capable of eliciting an
immune response is referred to as an antigen.
There are two broad classes of immune responses: 1) Humoral
antibody responses involve the production of a antibodies which
circulate in the bloodstream and bind specifically to the foreign
antigen that induced them and 2) Cell-mediated immune responses
which involve the production of specialized cells that react
mainly with foreign antigens on the surface of host cells. In
immunoelectron microscopy we are primarily concerned with humoral
responses that produce soluble antibodies.
Antibodies are produced by a class of cells known as B
lymphocytes. The only known function of B lymphocytes is in fact
to make antibodies. Antibodies are a unique group of proteins
that can exist in millions of different forms each with their own
unique binding site for antigen. Collectively they are call
immunoglobulins (abbrv. Ig). Most antibodies are bivalent, that
is they have two identical antigen binding sites. The antigen
binding site is composed of a heavy and a light chain each
containing about 220 amino acids. They are hinged by way of
their heavy chains to an Fc (Fc stands for Fragment
Crystallization).
[Figure 17-17 here]
There are five different classes of antibodies; IgA, IgD,
IgE, IgG, & IgM. They differ from one another in the composition
of their heavy chains. IgG antibodies constitute the major class
of immunoglobulin in the blood and are copiously produced during
secondary immune responses. It should be remembered that when
using monoclonal antibodies (single antigenic site vs. Polyclonal
= multiple antigenic sites on that antigen) the right portion of
the antigen must be presented to the surface of the section in
order for the antibody to recognize it and bind to it.
Immunogold labeling can be done in one of several ways. The
colloidal gold particles (5- 40 nm) are conjugated either
directly to the antibody being used or to an IgG or IgA protein.
In an indirect method the sections or tissue is first incubated
in the antibody of interest. Next the sample is exposed to a
secondary antibody that reacts to the IgG or IgA antibody of the
first animal. This secondary antibody is conjugated to a
colloidal gold particle which because of its electron density
allows one to visualize where in the cell the primary antibody
(and by implication the antigen) is localized.
One can even do double labeling experiments if gold
particles of two different sizes and different animal IgGs are
used. This requires using sections picked up on uncoated grids.
A number of other electron dense tags that can be used with
antibody labeling as well. Ferritin molecules (the storage
protein for iron in mammals) have a diameter of about 10 nm and
there iron component imparts their electron opacity. Horseradish
peroxidase (HRP) is an enzyme that can be coupled to primary
antibody and then allowed to form an electron dense reaction
product that is visualized. One alternative to using a secondary
antibody involves the use of protein A. Protein A is produced by
the bacterium Staphylococcus and can bind to the Fc portion of
IgG. Tagged protein A is often better suited for use as a
secondary label than is an anti IgG antibody.
There are a number of rules that one must follow in
performing immunoelectron microscopy. The first involves the
choice of grids. Some of the solutions that the sections will be
exposed to may react with the metal of the grid (e.g. copper
react with high salt conc. solutions). To avoid unwanted
chemical reactions one typically chooses grids made of
non-reactive metals. Nickel is a common choice as it is fairly
unreactive and relatively cheap. Others prefer solid gold grids
as these are the most inert. Coated or uncoated grids may be
used but sections should not be carbon coated after they are
picked up as this can make the sections hydrophobic.
A second rule that should be followed is to avoid
overfixation. This is often a difficult thing to balance as we
want to retain as much structural preservation as possible while
at the same time retain biological activity of molecules. These
are mutually incompatible goals. Excessive crosslinking with
glutaraldehyde can prevent the reactive sites of a molecule from
retaining its shape and therefore function and fixation with
osmium can render membranes impermeable and make membrane bound
biomolecules inaccessible. Sometimes osmium can be used as
fixative after the antibody labeling has been carried out, but
this can only be done in cases where the specimen is labeled
prior to embedding. A typical fixative for immunocytochemistry
studies would be a mixture of 4.0% paraformaldehyde and 0.1%
glutaraldehyde in the proper buffer. This will provide
reasonable ultrastructural preservation while preventing
excessive cross linking. Often sections on grids are initially
soaked on a drop of saturated sodium metaperiodate. This reacts
with any unbound or unreacted glutaraldehyde in the sections and
prevents the glutaraldehyde from crosslinking the antibodies when
they are applied to the sections. Freeze substituted specimens
must of course be rehydrated if pre-embedding labeling is to be
done otherwise this method is an excellent fixation choice
(assuming that fixatives have been left out of the substitution
fluid. Of course unfixed material such as found with
cryosectioning offers the best cross reactivity but structural
preservation and image contrast is often very poor. They offer
the advantage of never having been fixed, retaining water soluble
components, and having not embedding medium to penetrate.
Sometimes sections are "etched" to make the antigens contained
within it more accessible. A unique application of this involves
polystyrene embedding and acetone etching. Prolonged exposure
can remove all of the embedding resin leaving only the specimen
after sectioning. This is similar to xylene extraction of
paraffin sections.
Another type of immunolableing involves the use of Avidin.
Avidins are a class of basic glycoproteins that have a MW of
about 65,000 and can be found in large amounts in egg white or Streptomyces. They are useful in immuno EM because of their high
affinity binding for biotin. Each avidin molecule has four
biotin-binding sites per molecule. Many biomolecules can be
labeled with biotin (biotinylated) including proteins, lectins,
fluorescent beads, and nucleic acid bases. When one treats a
sample with gold or ferritin conjugated avidin it selectively
binds to the biotinylated molecule and the metal atoms acts an
electron dense marker of where the biomolecule of interest is
localized.
Enzyme Cytochemistry: [text 254-261]
In addition to the anitbody/antigen type of reactions there
are other biochemical reactions that can be utilized to visualize
the localization of biological compounds in the TEM. One of
these is the very specific reactions that can take place between
certain enzymes and their substrates. The reactions can be
utlilized to localize the presence of a given enzyme in a
specimen. The technique works by trapping the resultant reaction
product between the enzyme and the substrate and visualizing it.
As with immunoEM the initial fixation of the specimen must
be sufficient to preserve structure while at the same time no
degrading the enzyme's ability to react with substrate. A
fixation similar to the ones used in immunoEM is often employed.
Because enzymatic reactions are sensitive to environmental
conditions such a pH, temperature, and substrate concentrations
all of these need to be taken into account. Finally, unlike gold
particles the reaction product may be only weakly electron opaque
therefore at least some of the sections are usually viewed prior
to post staining. One interesting note is that enzymatic
labeling is often best accomplished using epoxide resins rather
than methacrylates. It is believed that the hydrophilic nature
of methacrylates allows the enzyme to easily access the
substrate, carry out the reaction, and then detach. Since we
want the enzyme to remain attached to the substrate (thus showing
the localization of the substrate) it is actually better to use
resins that are more difficult to penetrate and therefore more
difficult for the enzyme to release from.
The reaction between horseradish peroxidase (HRP) which is
an enzyme that reacts with peroxide and through the addition of
DAB and oxidation with OsO4 forms and insoluable electron dense
precipitate. Sometimes HRP is coupled to an antibody and then a
reaction product formed through the addition of the proper
components to form an insoluable precipitate. The earliest use
of this involved ferritin- HRP complex but this may have a
reduced access to the lectin binding sites due to steric
hindrance. Recently HRP has been electrostatically bound to
colloidal gold and thus used as an indirect marker for lectin
binding sites. This avoids the steric hindrance problem and
gives a better indication of lectin binding site distribution.
Alternative Methods [280-285]
Lectins:
Lectins are plant compounds that have specific affinities
for certain carbohydrates. They may be tagged and used as a
probe for the presence of these oligosaccharides.
Naturally occurring compounds:
Molecules that normally bind or react with one another can
be utilized
One final type of biochemical localization involves the use
of Diaminobenzidine (DAB). DAB specifically binds to sulfated
mucopolysaccharides when exposed to them at low pH. The DAB can
subsequently be oxidized by exposure to Osmium tetroxide. The
resulting electron dense precipitate is then an indication of
where the sulfated polysaccharides are localized. A second
rather use of DAB takes advantage of the fact that DAB can become
oxidised by U.V. irradiation. If a sample is first made
fluorescent by either labeling with a fluorescent dye or
conjugated molecule, then bathed in DAB and finally exposed to
the wavelength of light that will excite the fluorochrome, the
energy absorbed will oxidise the DAB which in turn will form an
insoluable, electron dense precipitate. This precipitate will
therefore be colocalized with the fluorescent marker. This
reaction also takes place with autofluorescent compounds that are
naturally found in cells therefore making the cytochromes of
mitochondria and the chlorophylls of chloroplasts sites where DAB
precipitation will take place. The technique has the advantage
of allowing fluorescent and EM studies to be done on the same
sample and is an excellent way of positively identifying the
biological structure that was originally labeled.
Sections have thickness to them and are not really flat.
Things generally bind only to exposed molecules. Size of probe
and porosity of the embedding medium are two factors that
influence immunolabeling. For this reason hydrophilic
methacrylate resins such as LR White and Lowicryl are often used
in immunoelectron and cytochemical microscopic studies and epoxy
resins generally avoided. This is not to say that epoxy resins
cannot be used, only that if labeling is poor the choice of resin
should be re-evaluated. Labeled sections are usually post
stained after immunolabeling with uranyl acetate or lead citrate
to provide contrast to the sample.
Stereology [text 288-303]
We have seen how the TEM can be used for descriptive work,
and to learn information and about the spatial distribution of
biomolecules. A third type of information that is available to
us using the TEM is quantitative information about the specimen
and geometric or three dimensional information. Geometric
information is known as stereology and image quantification is
known as morphometry. The techniques used in both of these
applications is based on the assumption that relative to the
total size and volume of the original specimen any given section
can be considered as a two dimensional view. Some of the
parameters that can be measured using stereological approaches
include the quantification of area, volume, surface area, length,
and number of structures present.
One basic approach to stereology involves the use of grid
patterns or "test systems" that are used to overlie the
micrograph. By carefully recording the number of interactions
between structures in the micrograph and plots on test system one
can come up with an objective value rather than a subjective
"guess" for the number of interactions. Using these values one
can plug into various equations and derive values for the
parameter of interest.
For example if the percent area of a given object relative
to the surrounding structure is desired one can count the number
of interactions or "hits" that are scored when the structures in
questions coincide with the intersection of the grid squares or
even lines. If one then compares the number of intersections
with the structure (Ns) and the total (Nt) and compares
Ns/Nt one can obtain a ratio and multiply by 100 to obtain a
value for percent area of the structure. The fineness of the
grid system will largely determine the accuraccy of this estimate
as well as the time required to do the counting.
If one takes repeated area measurements from adjacent serial
sections a volume can be calculated for the object. Two values
are needed to do this. The first is of course accurate area
measurements for each section. We have already seen how these
values can be approximated. The other is section thicknes.
Since we are only viewing a two dimensional view of a three
dimensional object (the section DOES have a hieght or "z"
component to it) we need to know this to plug into the equation:
V = Areas X avg. section thickness
The reflectance color of a section is a good way of
estimating the thickness of a section (much better than relying
on the microtome settings) but can vary 10%-20% and also varies
with the type of resin used. A more accurate method involves
re-embedding the section and cutting it transversely and then
viewing and measuring it in the TEM. This of course destroys the
original section. Other methods such as section tilting and
carefully measuring the relative distance changes for objects in
the plane of tilt can also be used but are somewhat cumbersome.
A simple and farily accurate method takes advantage of sharp
folds in the section and the esitmate that the total section
thickness is one half the fold width. The most accurate method
involves using plastic beads of a known diameter (determined from
high resolution SEM or negative stained TEM) and secitoning these
along with the specimen. By counting the total number of
sections needed to go through the sphere and dividing the
sphere's diameter by this number the average section thickness
can be determined.
Stereology Cont'd
To a large extent computer analysis of electron micrographs
has largely replaced many of these classic stereologic
techniques. The first generation of these took advantage of a
digitizing pallet linked to a computer with specialized software.
By tracing the image from either negatives or prints the
essential information is entered into the computer for the
software to use. Such variables as length of convoluted lines or
areas of irregular objects are easily calculated by the computer.
These values can be incorporated into a spreadsheet program and
quantified. Such hand enetered data sets can also be used in
three dimensional reconstruction applications to visualize
structures that span several planes and calculate values for
volume measurements.
More sophisticated software can now digitize the images
without the use of hand tracings. Images are either digitized by
placing the micrograph under a video camera or directly through
the use of a CCD mounted beneath the camera in the TEM column.
The operator then highlights the structures of interest (usually
by discriminating on grey levels) and then the computer will
automatically calculate unit measurements. This can be extremely
useful when one is attempting to perform particle counting or
other such applications.
X-ray Microanalysis [text
332-344]
Another class of signals produced by the interaction of the
primary electron beam with the specimen come under the category
of characteristic X- rays. When an electron from an inner atomic
shell is displaced by colliding with a primary electron, it
leaves a vacancy in that electron shell. In order to
re-establish the proper balance in its orbitals following an
ionization event, an electron from an outer shell of the atom may
"fall" into the inner shell and replace the spot vacated by the
displaced electron. In doing so the this falling electron loses
energy and this energy is referred to as X- radiation or X-rays.
In addition to characteristic X-rays, other X-rays are
produced as a primary electron decelerates in response to the
Columbic field of an atom. This "braking radiation" or
Bremsstrahlung X-ray is not specific for the element that causes
it and so these X-rays do not contribute useful information about
the sample and in fact contribute to the background X-ray signal.
For each electron/specimen interaction there are specific
electron replacement events that can take place. We speak of
these events as either K, L, or M replacement events depending on
which orbital shell lost the electron.
[Fig. 15-8]
We can further dissect these electron replacement events by
speaking of them in terms of which outer orbital electrons served
as the replacement for the displaced electron. If the
replacement electron came from an adjacent orbital shell it is an
alpha event, if it came from two shells away it is a beta event,
if the electron was donated from three shells away it is a gamma
event. Within a given shell there may be several different
orbitals, any of which could donate the replacement electron.
Thus we could speak of a K alpha1 or a K alpha2 replacement. The
important thing to note is that each electron replacement event
for each element gives off a specific amount of energy as the
replacement electron goes from a higher energy state to a lower
energy state. This change in energy is released in the form of
x-rays and because of the specific nature of these x-rays they
are call "characteristic x-rays."
By using special detectors that can discriminate between the
different characteristic x-rays one can obtain information about
the elemental composition of the specimen. Let's assume that a
plant cell is found to have in thin sections an electron dense
inclusion of unknown composition. By bombarding the inclusion
with electrons from the beam we drive off a number of electrons
which are replaced by outer orbital electrons and give off
characteristic x-rays for the elements in the specimen. Since we
are primarily interested in the composition of the inclusion and
not the surrounding tissue it is very beneficial to be able to
focus the beam to a single spot and position this over the object
on interest. This can best be done in a Scanning Transmission
Electron Microscope or STEM. A STEM is equipped with a set of
scan coils and can function in much the same way as an SEM by
rastering the beam (reduced to a small spot) over the specimen
which in this case would be a section on a grid. Also because
more of a sample will contain more of the material in question we
tend to cut thicker sections for x-ray microanalysis than we
would for straight visualization. Sections of 100-250 nm are
typically used. Finally, because certain elements produce their
own characteristic x-rays that may interfere with or obscure the
ones of the unknown sample, we tend to avoid osmicating the
specimen and avoid UA and lead staining. Also the choice of
metal grid can be important as grids composed of one metal (e.g.
nickel) may not overlap whereas others (e.g. copper) may.
By collecting the x-ray signals produced over an extended
period of time (e.g. 100 seconds) certain electron replacement
events will occur more frequently than others. We collect for
100 seconds of longer so that the more frequent events will
reinforce each other and thereby become distinct from the
background (characteristic x-rays from other elements) and
continuum x-rays. These repeated energy spectra manifest
themselves in the form of distinct peaks. Next with the aid of a
computer we can assign a numerical value for the midpoint of each
peak and scan through the values from known samples to find the
most logical match to our observed spectra. In trying to assign
a match it is important to note that for a given element there
will be more K alpha events than K beta events, and more K beta
events than K gamma events. Thus if one suspects the presence of
a given element due to the match between a collected peak and the
K beta peak of a known element, there should be a corresponding K
alpha peak for that element that is larger than the suspected K
beta peak.
There are basically two types of x-ray detectors available
for TEM and SEM. These are Energy Dispersive X-ray (EDX)
detectors and Wavelength Dispersive X- ray (WDS) detectors. They
function in quite different ways.
EDX detectors are the most versatile, cost effective and
hence most widely used type of x-ray detectors. EDX detectors
are composed of a silicon semi- conductor that has been doped
with lithium and are therefore referred to as SiLi detectors.
The EDX detector works by measuring the change in conductivity
that occurs when the semi-conductor absorbs excess energy in the
form of x-radiation. The conductivity increase is directly
proportional to the magnitude of the x- rays and so by carefully
measuring this increase one can knows the level of x- radiation
that was absorbed by the detector. Since these changes are still
relatively small the detector is kept a liquid nitrogen
temperatures to reduce electronic noise that would degrade peak
resolution. Since the internal environment of the TEM is subject
to minor (introduction of specimen) to major (venting of the
column) changes the detector must be kept in an exceptionally
clean environment. To do this it is typically shielded behind a
very thin seal or window. Beryllium is the material of choice
for such a window. Because of its low atomic weight (4)
beryllium will not block the x-rays of higher energy that are
produced by elements of higher atomic weight. It will however
reduce the ability to detect x-rays of relatively low energy
(such as those given off by elements of low atomic weight) and
make the detection of "light" elements more problematic. To
avoid this some systems have gone over to a windowless detector
which depends on the purity of the TEM environment from
contaminating the cold EDX detector.
The second type of x-ray detector is base on WDS. In WDS
crystals of known composition and structure are placed on a
movable turret relative to the x-ray source and a simple detector
(alternatively the detector itself is movable relative to the
crystal. Electrons and x-rays will move through a crystal and be
reflected or diffracted based on the particular arrangement of
molecules in that crystal. Only those energy sources entering
from a specific angle relative to the matrix arrangement of the
crystal will be so deflected. The angle by which this takes
place is known as the "Bragg angle" and is dependent to some
extent on the energy of the incoming radiation.
Bragg Equation:
where = an integer (1, 2, 3, etc.)
= the x-ray wavelength
= the interplanar spacing of the crystal
= angle of incidence
[Fig 5.2 Goldstein]
The crystal is often polished to a curved surface so that
the collected x- rays can be focused onto the actual detector.
The detector is a thin wire kept at a high positive voltage in an
argon/methane environment. As the x-rays pass through a thin
plastic window they ionize the gas mixture and conduct electrons
to the wire. This current flow is carefully measured and is
proportional to the energy of the x-ray which in turn reveals
information about the source of the x- rays.
WDX is more quantitative than EDX but has a number of
disadvantages to it. The most important of these is the fact
that each type of crystal has a relatively narrow x-ray energy
range that it can deflect. Thus each crystal and detector can
only detect a small range of elements whereas an EDX detector can
detect nearly the entire spectrum of elements. Because of this
one often needs a suite of WDX detectors, each with a different
type of crystal and responsible for a different portion of the
periodic table. This means having a number of open ports
available near the specimen. On most TEMs we do not have this
luxury and so WDX systems are usually found on a special class of
SEM known as a microprobe. X-ray analysis on TEM and STEM is
usually accomplished with an EDX system.
Electron Diffraction [text
347-355]
We have seen several methods whereby we can learn more about
the specimen than just its appearance. Although not widely used
by biologists electron diffraction is a powerful TEM technique
that can provide important information about the molecular
arrangement of crystalline specimens.
Electrons are forward scattered or "diffracted" as they come
in contact with molecules in the specimen. Most of the time this
results in a random deflection of the illuminating electrons and
creates a fuzzy or muddled quality to the final image. This is
caused by the fact that a deflected electron will create just as
bright a spot on the fluorescent screen or TEM film as will an
undeflected electron. Because a randomly scattered electron may
hit the screen in a region that would normally appear dark due to
the presence of an electron dense body immediately above it. To
reduce the effect of these randomly scattered electrons one
typically places a small diameter aperture in the objective lens
immediately beneath the specimen. Although this reduces overall
illumination and reduces resolution by decreasing the angle of
the cone of incident illumination, it increases image contrast by
eliminating most of the forward scattered electrons.
[draw diagram]
The situation is quite different when the electrons of the
beam encounter a crystalline specimen. A crystalline specimen is
one in which the molecules of the specimen are arranged in such a
way as to form a close-packed lattice array with individual
molecules arranged in a very ordered and repetitive structure.
If the electrons strike a crystalline structure at the proper
angle they will all be diffracted from the individual planes of
the lattice in the same angle and same direction and brought to
the same focal point. This focal point lies in the same plane as
the one in which transmitted electrons come to focus and is known
as the back focal plane of the objective lens.
[Fig. 15-26]
Electron Diffraction Cont'd
The angle at which the incident electrons encounter the
specimen is the most critical parameter in creating a sharp
electron diffraction pattern. This angle is known as the Bragg
Angle. A crystalline specimen that is placed on grid may
intially lie at any random angle relative to the incident beam.
To orient the specimen so that the incident beam strikes at the
proper Bragg angle and generates a sharp diffraction pattern it
is necessary to tilt and rotate the specimen until a clear
pattern is formed. If the beam strikes the lattice at the proper
Bragg angle electrons that are scattered from the same point in
the specimen are brought together at a single point in the image
plane. Likewise electrons scattered from different points in the
specimen BUT deflected in the same direction and angle will
converge in the back focal plane of the objective lens.
[Fig. 15-30]
If one can obtain a picture of this pattern and carefully
measure the spacings between these spots of convergence much can
be learned about the molecular structure and composition of the
specimen.
The spacing between lattice planes can be calculated from
the diffraction pattern using the following equation:
d= L/R
Where d = Spacing between planes
= Wavelength of electron (based accelerating voltage)
L = Camera length (distance in mm between specimen and
camera)
R = Distance from center spot to bright dots on negative
It is important that these calculations be done on the negative
itself. If done on prints the exact enlargement factor must be
known so that the R measurements can divided by this number.
Since the camera length is a critical portion of this equation it
should be regularly calibrated. This is done not by measuring
with a ruler but by creating a diffraction pattern with a
standard sample of known d spacing at a given accelerating
voltage and calculating the value for L by plugging R into the
equation.
Intermediate And High Voltage EM [text
360-367]
Theoretical resolution in a transmission optical instrument
can never exceed 1/2 the wavelength of the illumination. de
Broglie's equation for calculating the wavelength of an excited
electron is
= h/mv
Where = wavelength
h = Planck's constant (6.626 X 10-23 ergs/sec)
m = mass of electron
v = velocity of electron
By plugging in known values this equation can be reduced to
= (1.23/ V )nm Where V = Accelerating Voltage
In theory then the higher the accelerating voltage, the shorter
the wavelength, the greater the resolution capability! If 100 kV
is good 1000 kV (one million volts or 1 MV) is better! This type
of accelerating voltage is known as High Voltage Electron
Microscopy or HVEM.
A second advantage of HVEM is the ability of the beam to
penetrate a specimen. Even a 125 kV TEM cannot penetrate a very
thick specimen and most of our knowledge of the three dimensional
nature of biological structures is from reconstructions made of
serial thin sections each of which was laboriously sectioned,
photographed, and pieced back together. Electrons that are
accelerated to only 125 kV are more widely scattered than those
of a 1 MV TEM. Because of this thicker specimens can be used
than are possible with a conventional TEM. By viewing a greater
portion of the specimen at a single time stereo pair images can
be formed of a single thick section and viewed to gain three
dimensional information about the specimen. This is best done on
specimens that contain no embedding resin which would only serve
to scatter the electrons.
A final advantage of HVEM is that because fewer of the beam
electrons interact with the specimen (they are moving by too
fast) specimen damage tends to be less in a HVEM than in a
conventional TEM (assuming the same thickness sections). Of
course, since one of the primary reasons for using a HVEM is to
look at thick sections, this advantage is often canceled out by
the increased number of interactions with the specimen.
One major drawback to HVEM is $. Although the optical
systems are essentially the same as those found on conventional
TEMs the components associated with the 1 MV accelerating system
usually means that HVEMs are several stories tall and require a
special building dedicated to their use. There are only a
handful of active HVEMs in the U.S. and less than 30 world wide.
Most of these were built in the 1950's or 1960's. In an effort
to gain some of the advantages without all of the expense a
number of TEM manufacturers have introduced Intermediate Voltage
Electron Microscopes (IVEMs). Although generally costing more
than a conventional TEM, IVEMs can be housed in the same places
as conventional TEMs and can also be operated at lower (80 - 100
kV) accelerating voltages. IVEMs and HVEMs are most popular
among materials scientists use images of lattice images are often
only possible at very high accelerating voltages.
One of the major discoveries of cellular structure was found
through the use of HVEM, this being the complex microtrabecular
lattice that is believed to extend throughout the cytoplasm of
cells. There are many however who believe that this lattice is
an artifact of dehydration and specimens are properly critical
point dried no such lattice exists!